For those who, like me, should not a patent lawyer and don’t perceive patent legislation, however your boss asks you to show your just lately written piece of code right into a patent, learn on. The boss most likely received’t ask you to jot down all the patent. As a substitute, he’ll ask you to organize a fast abstract of the invention (normally, a couple of slides) after which a employed lawyer will flip it right into a full-scale patent utility. For those who perceive the aim of patents, the mechanics of patent workplaces, and the format of a patent declare, you’ll just do positive.
![And Justice for All (1979) by Norman Jewison](https://www.yegor256.com/images/2024/06/and-justice-for-all.jpg)
What are patents for? Initially invented as a instrument to encourage harmless inventors, they’re at the moment used principally as a weapon both to bully bigger organizations or to defend them in opposition to bullying. It began in Italy in 1474, when a three-year “grant” was given to Filippo Brunelleschi for “some machine or sort of ship,” for a interval of three years. Since then, over 3.5 million patents have been issued by totally different patent workplaces across the globe to revered inventors.
What’s a patent office? It’s a safety group funded by a authorities: USPTO in the USA, EPO within the European Union, CNIPA in China, Rospatent in Russia, IPOS in Singapore, and a few dozen in different nations. Additionally, there’s WIPO in Geneva (Switzerland) that coordinates the work of all different POs, to date. They defend you for those who pay them (no shock it began in Italy!)
Let’s say you invent a brand new file compression algorithm and also you don’t need anybody to make use of it with out your permission. First, you pay $320 to USPTO and submit an utility. Then, in a couple of months, they assign your utility a quantity and name it “pending.” Then, you await about 3.5 years till they reply again with a choice: both you get a patent, you get nothing, or they ask you to refine the appliance (commonest case). You make the modifications, resubmit, they criticize, you resubmit, … and finally they concern a patent.
Now what? Your organization publishes a press launch, informs all traders, you make a Fb put up in order that your mother may be happy with you, and in a couple of days everyone forgets about it. As a result of no person cares. Till the litigation day comes: your organization finds out that one other firm can also be compressing recordsdata utilizing the identical algorithm. Or, the opposite method round: they discover out that the algorithm you invented is definitely the algorithm they’ve been quietly utilizing for years. You each meet in a patent court. The USPTO might be there too, because you paid them earlier.
In case your opponent doesn’t have a patent, the decide will ask them to show that their compression algorithm was publicly accessible previous to your utility. If they supply such proof, your patent might be infringed—you’ll lose it, your $320 received’t be refunded, and you’ll pay the whole lot you remodeled the previous couple of years to the opponent.
In case your opponent does have a patent, you’ll have to show that your patent is older and broader. USPTO attorneys most likely received’t attempt that can assist you, since they received’t be in your facet, however merely a mediator between each of you (Apple vs. Samsung litigation is an efficient instance of such a patent conflict). For those who win, their patent might be infringed and you’ll get all of the revenue they managed to gather over the past years. Huge win!
What’s patent breadth? First, let’s talk about what’s its size. It’s possible you’ll be stunned, however patents have fairly quick lifetimes. For those who don’t prolong a patent, it’ll expire in simply three years. For those who do wish to prolong it, it’s essential to pay USPTO again and way more than you paid the primary time: $2,000 in 3 years, $3,760 in 7 years, $7,700 in 11 years. Not low-cost, huh?
Now, the breadth. Think about three patent claims:
- “An equipment consisting of a file reader; a file author; and a compressor.”
- “A file compressing technique comprising a reader of JPEG recordsdata; a likelihood distribution calculator; a discrete transformer; a bla-bla-bla optimizer; an intermediate storage; a author of JPEG recordsdata.”
- “A Lempel–Ziv based mostly knowledge compression technique comprising: changing enter stream into ψ-tokens; decreasing redundancy by way of Prishvin Ω(x) factorials; serializing by Turgenev 𝛾-extremums.”
The primary declare is far broader: it most likely covers all attainable file compressing software program instruments ever created. Such a broad patent declare received’t even be accepted by USPTO for those who file it. They may do a fast search of prior artwork (different patents beforehand issued) and reject you on the idea of a scarcity of novelty. The second declare is narrower, however nonetheless fairly broad, because the structure of different present compressors could also be similar to the described one. The third declare is probably the most slender and probably the most particular (though, have completely no sense, it’s made up).
write a very good patent declare? There isn’t a such factor as an objectively good claim, because it relies on the state of affairs out there. If the territory of innovation is just not but developed and you’re a pioneer, a broader and shorter (by the size in years, not the variety of phrases) patent is best. If you’re making a small enchancment to a well-developed prior artwork, higher make the patent narrower and longer.
A patent declare is the important thing aspect of a patent utility. Whereas the remainder of the doc could also be written by a patent lawyer, I strongly recommend you write the declare. A minimum of its first model. There’s a kind of strict construction of a declare: preamble, transitional phrase, and physique:
Preamble | Transitional Phrase | Physique |
---|---|---|
An equipment | consisting of | a file reader; a file author; and a compressor. |
A file compressing technique | comprising | a reader of JPEG recordsdata; a likelihood distribution calculator; a discrete transformer; a bla-bla-bla optimizer; an intermediate storage; a author of JPEG recordsdata. |
A Lempel–Ziv based mostly knowledge compression technique | comprising | changing enter stream into ψ-tokens, decreasing redundancy by way of Prishvin Ω(x) factorials, serializing by Turgenev 𝛾-extremums. |
The preamble should place your invention amongst all different units and strategies within the prior artwork. The “an equipment” preamble may be very broad: it might imply any machine on the planet, even not solely from the computing area. The “a file compressing technique” preamble is far narrower, whereas “a Lempel–Ziv based mostly knowledge compression technique” is probably the most slender one, with virtually no ambiguity for the interpretation.
The physique of a patent claim should iterate the weather that represent the invention. The less components you embrace on this listing, the broader the patent might be. The broader the patent, the better to infringe. Effectively, except you invent one thing revolutionary new. Then again, the extra components, the narrower the patent, the weaker it’s as a weapon. Will probably be very arduous to make use of a slender patent in a patent litigation.
The declare should even be non-obvious, which means that your invention needs to be an ample distance past or above the state-of-the-art. Say, a brand new file format is invented for graphic pictures and also you submit a patent utility for a ZIP compressor that may additionally compress recordsdata on this new format. If there isn’t any novelty within the compression algorithm itself, such a patent could be thought of apparent because it’s not distant from prior artwork: present ZIP compressors can cope with this file format, regardless that they don’t learn about it but.
How do you determine? It’s your duty as a patent writer to determine how broad and the way lengthy your patent should be. Then, a patent lawyer will make it easier to flip your patent declare right into a patent utility (charging a few thousand dollars alongside the best way), after which, hopefully, the litigation day will come and you’ll win some huge cash. Most likely this can by no means occur and the patent will stay a pleasant badge in your CV and your organization’s web site.
By the best way, it is very important do not forget that if you wish to get comparable safety abroad, you’ll have to pay their patent workplace individually. Similar to you pay each time a distinct mafia boss for cover if you wish to work within the territories they management.